Is lleva interchangeable with está and what is the difference between the two? Thank you
In Spanish we can use the verb llevar followed by a gerund (Gerundio) in order to express the duration of a still-ongoing action:
llevar (conjugated) + gerund
Have a look at the following examples:
Carlos lleva trabajando en ese colegio dos años.Carlos has been working in that school for two years.
Notice how:
- the time phrase (tres días, diez minutos, dos años...) can be placed either at the end of the verbal structure or in between the verb llevar and the gerund.
- the Spanish tenses used with this structure are El Presente and El Pretérito Imperfecto. The perfect tenses are not used.
- However, note that the equivalent tenses in English are the perfect tenses or the progressive perfect tenses (have done, have been doing, had been doing,...)
The negative form
If we want to express the same but in the negative, the structure changes to:
llevar (conjugated) + sin + infinitive
For example:
You can see that in the negative form, the time phrase can also be placed straight after llevar, or after the whole structure.
Learn more about these related Spanish grammar topics
Examples and resources
Q&A Forum 2 questions, 3 answers
InmaKwiziq team member
Hola Emanuel
No, they are not interchangeable. Take for example one of the sentences from the lesson:
Carlos lleva trabajando en ese colegio dos años.
Carlos has been working in that school for two years.
If we try with the perfect tense of estar:
Carlos ha estado trabajando en ese colegio dos años.
Carlos has been working in that school for two years.
The sentence is grammatically correct but using estar doesn't imply that he is still working in the school, he may be, he may not be. With "lleva + gerund" it always implies that the event is still ongoing in the present.
So they are similar sentences but with a different nuance.
Hope this helps.
Inma
EmanuelKwiziq Q&A regular contributor
If we said: Carlos está trabajando en ese colegio desde hace dos años would't it imply he is still working there? or do we have to use the present tense: Carlos trabaja en ese colegio desde hace dos años?
Emanuel asked:View original
Lleva vs. está
Is lleva interchangeable with está and what is the difference between the two? Thank you
Don't have an account yet? Join today
NickKwiziq community member
Hi - done this test a few times now and score won't go above 33% despite not getting any wrong :)
Asked 10 months ago
InmaKwiziq team member
Hola Nick
Just so you know I've asked someone to look into this and we will be getting back to you!
Saludos
Inma
Nick asked:View original
Hi - done this test a few times now and score won't go above 33% despite not getting any wrong :)
Don't have an account yet? Join today
