Aquella sombrilla estaba rota.

Ross A.B2Kwiziq community member

Hi, I have a question about the grammar of this sentence. I apologize it doesn’t have to do with “aquella.” Just wondering about the use of “estaba.” Why not “estuvo?” For something to be broken is that not permanent? Or is it because it was fixed that it “used to be broken”? Am I over thinking this?

This question relates to:Spanish lesson "Demonstrative adjectives: aquel, aquella, aquellos, aquellas = that/those in Spanish [over there] (Adjetivos demostrativos)"

Asked 3 years ago

Like0Answer1

InmaNative Spanish expert teacher in Kwiziq

Hola Ross

We are using estaba rota (not estuvo rota) because this sentence is "descriptive" and there is no interest in highlighting any timeframe. Here's a lesson that talks about this. Have a look.

Saludos

Inma

Like03 years ago

Ross A. asked:

Aquella sombrilla estaba rota.

Hi, I have a question about the grammar of this sentence. I apologize it doesn’t have to do with “aquella.” Just wondering about the use of “estaba.” Why not “estuvo?” For something to be broken is that not permanent? Or is it because it was fixed that it “used to be broken”? Am I over thinking this?

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today