Agreement of demonstrative pronoun

PaoloC1Kwiziq community member

Agreement of demonstrative pronoun

In the example: 

Nuestra ayuda está dirigida a jóvenes sin empleo. Estas son personas que han acabado sus estudios y no han encontrado trabajo.

why is it "Estas" and not "Estos"? Doesn't this pronoun need to agree with "jóvenes" rather than "personas"?


Asked 1 year ago
InmaKwiziq team member

Hola Paolo

In this case the demonstrative is agreeing with the gender of "personas": estas

As you have the noun jóvenes before and it is actually referring to them you would think that you need the masculine: estos (estos [jóvenes] son personas que...) and that would also be correct.

It is something to do with the word "personas" and because we are considering these "young people" as "persons" we used straight away the gender attributed to "personas" instead of "jóvenes". Its as if we are saying "Estas [personas jóvenes] son personas que..."

It's a bit difficult to explain. I hope you got the idea...

Saludos

PaoloC1Kwiziq community member

Hmm. Strange. I wonder if what is happening grammatically is actually that you can either use the demonstrative pronounEstos [jóvenes] son personas que...

Or else a demonstrative adjective: Estas personas (son los) que...  but allowing the verb to go in-between the adjective and the noun.

In any case, an interesting construction. Thanks!

Agreement of demonstrative pronoun

In the example: 

Nuestra ayuda está dirigida a jóvenes sin empleo. Estas son personas que han acabado sus estudios y no han encontrado trabajo.

why is it "Estas" and not "Estos"? Doesn't this pronoun need to agree with "jóvenes" rather than "personas"?


Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your Spanish level for FREE

Test your Spanish to the CEFR standard

Find your Spanish level
Thinking...