specifing to whom or what?

AmitKwiziq community member

specifing to whom or what?

Hi I'm trying to learn Spanish and I came across a sentence which caused my learning app and my native Spanish speaking  partner to disagree:


The original sentence from the learning app: "Si puede, deles una explicacion a sus alumnos"


My partner say it's wrong, and it should be "Si puede, dele una explicacion a sus alumnos"


Since it refers to giving an explanation which is singular and not plural.


To my understanding, it should be plural because it's given to the students.


Which one is the right one??


Thanks! 




Asked 5 days ago
InmaKwiziq team memberCorrect answer

Hola Amit

It is grammatically correct with "deles" because here, "les" is an indirect object pronoun that is referring to the plural "a sus alumnos". 

It is nevertheless a common use and you will hear it quite often with a singular pronoun "le" even though when it should be plural. But if we are talking about being accuracy in grammar, you need "les".

Other examples where you may hear/read "le" instead of the correct "les" could be for example:

"No le(s) pongas mostaza a las hamburguesas."

Don't put any mustard to (on) the burgers.

"Ella le(s) dijo a los invitados que tenían que llevar corbata."

She told the guests that they had to wear a tie.

Here is some information about this "non-recommended" use of le. Have a look.

Saludos

Inma

specifing to whom or what?

Hi I'm trying to learn Spanish and I came across a sentence which caused my learning app and my native Spanish speaking  partner to disagree:


The original sentence from the learning app: "Si puede, deles una explicacion a sus alumnos"


My partner say it's wrong, and it should be "Si puede, dele una explicacion a sus alumnos"


Since it refers to giving an explanation which is singular and not plural.


To my understanding, it should be plural because it's given to the students.


Which one is the right one??


Thanks! 




Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your Spanish level for FREE

Test your Spanish to the CEFR standard

Find your Spanish level
Thinking...