Somos nosotros quienes + 1 plural or 3 plural?

Paul L.C1Kwiziq community member

Somos nosotros quienes + 1 plural or 3 plural?

Hola

Cual es correcta?

1. No fuimos nosotras quienes hicimos caer a esa mujer.

2. No fuimos nosotras quienes hicieron caer a esa mujer.


Cual es la regla? #3 con 1 plural y #4 con 3 plural.


3. Somos nosotros quienes podemos hacer la diferencia.

We're the ones who can make a difference.


4. Seamos nosotros quienes se hagan ricos con esto.

So it might as well be us who get rich on it.


Gracias de antemano

Asked 3 weeks ago
InmaKwiziq team memberCorrect answer

Hola Paul

In this type of sentence where the subject is implicit (nosotros) and is using a relative, in theory, the verb should be using the first person plural. However, it's not uncommon to use the 3rd person plural sometimes. The RAE has a chapter within the title "concordancia" that talks about this. With partitives for example it's common to find the 3rd person plural conjugation with nosotros. The RAE gives this example:

"Éramos los únicos que no trataban de halagarlo."

You can read a bit more about this here from the RAE page (it's in 33.6n and 33.6ñ)

Saludos cordiales

Inma

Somos nosotros quienes + 1 plural or 3 plural?

Hola

Cual es correcta?

1. No fuimos nosotras quienes hicimos caer a esa mujer.

2. No fuimos nosotras quienes hicieron caer a esa mujer.


Cual es la regla? #3 con 1 plural y #4 con 3 plural.


3. Somos nosotros quienes podemos hacer la diferencia.

We're the ones who can make a difference.


4. Seamos nosotros quienes se hagan ricos con esto.

So it might as well be us who get rich on it.


Gracias de antemano

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your Spanish level for FREE

Test your Spanish to the CEFR standard

Find your Spanish level
Thinking...